11 comments

  • colijobles 8 hours ago
    Brilliant application. Imagine the progress we could make with models post trained on scientific process and a good agentic process.

    I've been tinkering with the latter for the last couple of months. Yesterday my system made some progress on instabilities on a particular superconductive system: https://colinocallaghan.com/autonomous-ai-research/Spatial-P...

  • __alias 8 hours ago
    Laughed at the reddit comment

    > "We got vibe astronomy before GTA6"

  • ContinuityLab 9 hours ago
    Cool discovery, but I'd be real curious about the false-positive rate when letting coding agents loose on raw astronomical telemetry. Hallucinations in data reduction are no joke.
    • pizza234 9 hours ago
      From the discussion:

      > even got NASA to point a telescope at it for confirmation

    • colijobles 8 hours ago
      with a proper stats harness the false positive rate can be brought well down to acceptable levels
    • phoronixrly 9 hours ago
      Oh don't worry, after claude democratises astronomy the false positives will be cleaned up by the real astronomers. As seen in math and open-source development.

      This will be the first time I've had anything in common with a mathematician btw -- wading through heaps of claudeism-infested slop all day long.

      • binary132 3 hours ago
        They downvoted him because he spoke the truth.
  • higeorge13 10 hours ago
    This is incredible use of AI tools. Big kudos!
  • k310 9 hours ago
    Planet Claude?

    Asking for a friend.

  • amirkhanian 7 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • thatguy0900 3 hours ago
    [dead]
  • wartywhoa23 10 hours ago
    Found a planet and saved a granny. Wake me up when this planet is acknowledged by any astonomer community with more say than r/ClaudeAI.
    • thiht 6 hours ago
      Like NASA?
  • VCFundedGenYer 4 hours ago
    Vibe researching is not real researching. Leave it to the experts at NASA.
    • supersparrow 41 minutes ago
      Why? We have been allowing technology to progress us for decades. Why stop now?
    • black6 4 hours ago
      We're coming back around to an era of the Citizen Scientist.
  • soltanov 9 hours ago
    Call me when peer review confirms it; until then, it is noise fitting noise. (Reason: Clean cut through the hype directly to scientific validation.)
    • soltanov 4 hours ago
      I don't understand the downvotes on this topic. Almost everybody is in grey :)
  • _fuchs 9 hours ago
    So much AI in the writing. If you dont care to write i do not care to read.
    • frmrtntn 1 hour ago
      It's interesting that a few months ago your sentiment would have been upvoted. I've noticed recently that things seem to be flipping around. Sadly, I think it's inevitable that people will accept a form of communication that consists of people trading slop. Even worse, the author lies about using AI for the writeup in the comments.