21 comments

  • staminade 19 hours ago
    Interesting to see how they're attempting to implement this. Basically a crowdsourced agent swarm coordinated via GitHub issues, where people claim features to work on: https://github.com/ItsNotRexed/Leonida/issues/634
    • chii 15 hours ago
      Just like how Fallout New Vegas decompilation: https://www.reddit.com/r/FalloutMods/comments/1xpxr5b/holy_s...

      They basically broke the game down into large number of individual "functions", and have each contributor run their LLM of choice to produce the source that would match the bytes of the binary. This is a good contribution model - you can even have each function be done by more than one person to verify it even better.

      • 4gotunameagain 14 hours ago
        Crowd source decompilation is such a great idea, and such a great way to extract VC subsidised subscription tokens.

        One of the few instances where VC money have been used for good instead of "market capture" i.e. monopoly creation

      • xyzsparetimexyz 10 hours ago
        I'm not convinced this makes sense purely from a context point of view tbh. If you can do a matching decompile of 1 function in a file then it's only 5% more tokens for any other similar functions
        • rovr138 10 hours ago
          It doesn't make sense from a clean code point of view. But you're thinking someone's going to go in and modify something by hand.

          > then it's only 5% more tokens for any other similar functions

          Not if it's distributed and multiple nodes come up with it at the same time. But there's also no reason that passes could be done after if someone wanted to actually have clean code.

          It's a tradeoff

          • cassianoleal 7 hours ago
            Not like you need clean code for a video game either. This is not a project that will require long-term maintenance.
            • rovr138 7 hours ago
              And the compiler will still find optimizations and copy things to the right location on the compiled binaries.

              Once it builds, you can throw a profiler if you want to find bottlenecks. Find the same thing and you can start optimizing the code that makes sense.

              This is what happens with decompiling.. which is essentially what’s happening.

    • cedws 13 hours ago
      How do they defend from prompt injection? This seems like a disaster waiting to happen.
      • wallst07 10 hours ago
        Sandbox
        • cedws 10 hours ago
          That is not a defense.
          • crostlybostly 7 hours ago
            Is it not the best defense?
            • vicioussquid 4 hours ago
              Models have been able to escape sandboxes for a few years now. It is readily documented.
              • wallst07 3 hours ago
                Ok, if you can't figure out how to properly sandbox, don't run agents?
    • PeterStuer 4 hours ago
      How robust is this method in practice vs well funded adversarial poisonong?
    • blntechie 17 hours ago
      That's creative. Do they restrict which models can contribute, or recommend to use?
    • tda 17 hours ago
      This is exactly how Solidcraft is being built. So far it kinda seems to work. I donate my tokens at the end of my weekly window
    • jauntywundrkind 17 hours ago
      Reminds me a little bit of https://rainshare.dev , a new atproto app. Folks post asks for projects, and other people "donate" implementations. A push request?

      > Introducing mutual aid, for AI coding plans & usage limits!

      > Use Rainshare to find people who could use a hand with a software project/issue. Anyone with spare usage can send their agent to pitch in so it doesn’t get wasted. Nobody pays, and anyone can ask.

      https://bsky.app/profile/rainshare.dev/post/3n27litnp7k2q

      • dolmen 15 hours ago
        An then malicious task will extract personal data from the agent's data (MEMORY.md, installed MCP connectors) or install persistent external ownership.
        • rovr138 10 hours ago
          The one used to share extra usage could be isolated without memory, mcps, etc.

          Run it on docker or vm, rebuild it daily. That should clear the crap from others.

    • bitwize 18 hours ago
      Instead of crypto mining it's PR mining
      • therealdrag0 17 hours ago
        I often have plenty of spare tokens on my subscriptions, so I’ve wondered about having an automated way to donate it. Kinda like how there’s CPU time donation tools.
        • rovr138 10 hours ago
          It's like seti@home.
    • arecsu 19 hours ago
      That's pretty creative
    • deklesen 18 hours ago
      The future is now
    • 4b11b4 18 hours ago
      Wait what so everyone on some discord is throwing their sub at this? lol
  • bob1029 13 hours ago
    Many seem to think the console target is a downside but it's a fundamental part of why the art team was able to do what they did here. Knowing exactly what kind of performance your client will have in production means that you can take things to the absolute limit. Companies like Blizzard have to hedge like crazy with performance because they're on every platform.

    I suspect we will find that GTA6 is difficult to run at 60fps on any hardware.

    • biotechbio 1 hour ago
      I disagree. I think the near parity of the base PS5 and Xbox Series X game performance suggests that current performance of the game is more limited contractually than by hardware.

      The Series X has no FSR4.1 implementation, likely due to an unwillingness to have the game perform "better" on one of base flagship consoles than the other. I think it is entirely possible a lower native resolution, RT-off / RT-low config could run with FSR upscaling on Series X at least >40 FPS. I suspect the game is CPU limited and wouldn't achieve stable 60 at near any graphical setting on the consoles.

      But many PCs are significantly more capable than 6 year old console hardware.

    • rcbdev 12 hours ago
      The art team obviously missed the mark completely then, if they can't even keep their game from consistently dropping sub 20 FPS on pre-defined target systems.
      • syndacks 7 hours ago
        Yea, the art team missed the mark on GTA6
  • birdman3131 19 hours ago
    Why the hell does it need to scan your computer for where the game is? Two directories deep in every drive?

    "It finds your copy of the game by itself: it looks in Downloads, Desktop, Documents, Games, your home folder and the top of every drive, two folders deep. It recognises the version from a few file sizes, without reading anything large."

    Just ask me where the game is.

    This feels like really stupid behavior and I feel like anyone running this is asking for trouble.

    • jofzar 17 hours ago
      > Why the hell does it need to scan your computer for where the game is? Two directories deep in every drive?

      The answer is always either maliciousness or stupidity, with it being gamers and emulation, I am going to go on the side of stupidity.

      I have seen people unable to follow literally a 2 step guide with emulation before, so trying to stop people from being idiots is probably the goal.

      • arcfour 17 hours ago
        Not quite, the answer is really because it's AI slop (unfortunately), this is the exact kind of instruction leakage you would get if you gave AI this silly idea instead of it pushing back...
        • dolmen 15 hours ago
          No. This is just the kind of idea that AI brings by itself and where the human in control should pushback in a design phase.
        • nonethewiser 15 hours ago
          >this is the exact kind of instruction leakage you would get if you gave AI this silly idea

          Then its human slop.

    • alex_duf 13 hours ago
      I keep hearing that the generation that grew up with smartphones don't know what file systems are. So maybe that's that.

      I think we collectively have dumbed down the user experience of software so much that we've prevented our users from learning anything technical. It was coming from the right place but that's not good.

    • paxy 18 hours ago
      If you are running this (and any other similar cracked/pirated game or software) on a system that isn't fully sandboxed and airgapped you deserve what is coming to you.
      • wolvoleo 15 hours ago
        It's open source though. Edit: Ah I see what you mean, the exe they don't have yet isn't.
      • croes 15 hours ago
        How is it pirated if you need to own the game?
        • wolvoleo 15 hours ago
          I think is meant to use with the leaked copy from a few days ago
    • zbendefy 10 hours ago
      I agree 100%, this would be a red flag or at least a very suspicous way to do it.

      But how can you tell that an arbitrary program is not doing the same maliciously?

      You can monitor it using sysinternals or strace to see what files it accesses or see the source code but most of the time you won't.

    • bakugo 18 hours ago
      It's behavior that is obviously stupid in the eyes of a human. No human was significantly involved in the creation of this.
      • derangedHorse 3 hours ago
        No, this is definitely a decision made by a human. It's not hard to verify this either. Ask Opus 5.5 or GPT 6.2 Sol if it would be better for an application to use the explorer for user file selection or perform a scan by default.
    • EliRivers 7 hours ago
      I have a software tester who copies a desktop shortcut onto another test machine, thinking that to do so is to copy the entire software.

      Where is the software, one might ask. The answer would be a finger pointing at the monitor, at the shortcut on the desktop.

    • publlus_enigma 17 hours ago
      Because the AI that built this thought it would be a good idea to reduce friction.
      • eddythompson80 16 hours ago
        More likely the person prompting it said something like “can you just find the game files for me” and the AI took it as a directive to scan all possible location, presented the plan and the prompter said lgtm. I think a more normal approach would have been to pick a default place as a convention and allowed a selection if it’s not there.

        However, that is driven by a desire to reduce brittle behavior that would surely result in bugs and reported issues “hey, a bunch of my drives are network mapped drives and I set the default SMB client timeout to 20 minutes and as a result the discovery takes hours to finish when it can’t connect”, but now you can just assign that to Claude and have it do whatever

        • dolmen 15 hours ago
          My experience is that's the kind of behavior when the human in control just don't specify to Opus how the program gets the input files: it goes wild into designing a way to find the files without user input at all.
    • justsomehnguy 17 hours ago
      Just yesterday a guy on the thread about this asked "but when I click on the link nothing happens and I just get a blank screen".

      Thankfully he provided a screenshot where you can see what the URL which he tried to open begins with magnet:?xt=urn:btih:

      So no, this is exactly the level of a current computer user.

      • Mawr 14 hours ago
        As expected of the average user. But an expert should know this and accordingly not create a confusing UX where clicking something gives a blank page.

        The supposed "high level" user behind the design is the idiot here, not the user. He should know better.

    • Onavo 18 hours ago
      Put yourself into the shoes of a non technical user and it would make a lot more sense.

      It's a common UX pattern in game modding/piracy software. If you see Minecraft's MultiMC/PolyMC they have the same file scanning design. A lot of mod authors are vehemently opposed against their mods being distributed as part of a "pack" so the mod pack can't allow automated downloads of the mod in a compliant manner so they basically give the end user a CDN URL to click and then automatically pick up the mod once it's downloaded. The things we do to satisfy fragile dev egos. (And it's training users to have bad computer security habits)

      • Pannoniae 16 hours ago
        looks like someone's gotta make a project which just blatantly bundles them into a modpack anyway and says "well, what you gonna do now, huh?" ;)
        • woctordho 6 hours ago
          In China such modpacks are pretty common and no one gives a sh*t about C&D.
        • Onavo 14 hours ago
          You will have to self host it. Any US based hosting platform us subject to the DMCA and the petty mod authors will go as far as sending C&Ds.
    • ex-aws-dude 17 hours ago
      Was going to comment the same thing

      I guarantee only Claude/Codex would come up with something that stupid

      I can imagine the prompt “make it automatically find the file”

    • zombocomvibes 14 hours ago
      [dead]
  • easton 19 hours ago
    This is based on a leak of the Xbox version of GTA 6, per Reddit.

    I saw the file manifest and it looked like any other appx package, what’s the big difference between Xbox apps and Windows msix (modern) apps? Are there tons of custom Xbox frameworks?

    • indrora 3 hours ago
      Basically, Xbox applications are installed in a shell of an OS (called GameOS) that has just enough Windows to make it Windows. The applications are encrypted in transit and while cold.
      • intqeb 2 hours ago
        It actually runs games sandboxed essentially in their own VM by a custom Hypervisor....

        Therefore the SDK used to build for the XBOX platform is a custom subset OS/DirectX calls that don't necessarily have a direct comparative call on an x64 Windows OS however the more recompilation that's carried out the quicker standard calls will be recognised and mapped to optimised recreated code

  • Garlef 13 hours ago
    I think this will force studios to be on all platforms at launch.

    Similar to how piracy forced movie studios to coordinate the global release of blockbusters.

    Back in the day, movies were released with a big delay internationally.

    In 1999, I watched a pirated version of the phantom menace half a year before it was even released in Germany.

    • 233mhz 13 hours ago
      > I think this will force studios to be on all platforms at launch.

      You're very optimistic, I think in 15 years most gaming hardware will be in the cloud and 90% of gaming will be streamed and locked behind subscriptions

      • poisonborz 10 hours ago
        Again something that open source models defend us against. The harder the lockdown, the bigger the pushback.
      • cferry 9 hours ago
        I believe that's how it should be: if as a corporation you want to keep control over what is being done with your code, you run it on your own infrastructure instead of the customers'. Then secure boot, attestation and other property-depriving technical measures become irrelevant.
      • sph 13 hours ago
        You’re very optimistic, I think starting 2027 some AAA releases will be cloud gaming exclusives.
        • thepasch 4 hours ago
          I think GTA 6 is the only game that could maybe have pulled this off. I expect any game that really tries to do this to fail miserably at every commercial metric.
        • thenthenthen 6 hours ago
          100%
  • wmf 19 hours ago
    I wonder why they translate D3D12 to Vulkan. If the goal is Windows, just use D3D12?
    • bigyabai 18 hours ago
      Because even with native D3D12, you're going to be re-caching shaders since your GPU isn't the Xbox's GPU. Might as well translate it all to Vulkan for convenience and portability, there's no good reason not to.
      • xyzsparetimexyz 10 hours ago
        What convenience? Sounds less convenient not more.
        • bigyabai 4 hours ago
          Convenience for the players. It's trivial to auto-translate DX12 calls to Vulkan, and there's no real reason not to if the DX12 shader cache is invalidated. It opens the door to using tools like fossilize to re-cache shaders for your hardware, and removes the last portability blocker for most other OSes.
    • SV_BubbleTime 19 hours ago
      Claude made a decision with the information it had at the initial prompt.
  • onjectic 19 hours ago
    > Early. The game does not boot yet
    • SXX 19 hours ago
      There is no executable yet, but they can likely start work on generic xbox recompiler based off other games.
  • jmyeet 19 hours ago
    Rumor has it that Rockstar has pushed up the PC launch to Q1 2027. For anyone paying attention, the PC port has usually come at least a year after the console release. Also, Rockstar has historically straddled console releases (eg end of PS3 going into PS4) so they can sell it twice. Obviously that isn't an option now because who knows when we'll get a new console? Maybe never given the advances in reverse engineering and how accessible it is.

    I think of this like how piracy basically forced content holders to allow streaming of music, TV and movies. So I expect a PC port sooner than later and this is probably the end of the long-delayed PC ports, which I'm a big fan of. Rockstar isn't hurting here either. Even with an estimated budget of $1-2 billion, it's done nearly $4 billion in sales in the first few days so they're doing fine.

    I know I'll buy it when it comes out on PC regardless of what pirate copies exist.

    • Thaxll 16 hours ago
      There is no port right. The game is developped on PC, dev use the PC version all day long, it's just a marketing stall.

      Every console games are developped on PC.

      • gambiting 15 hours ago
        I'm a game dev - yes you're strictly right that we always had a version of every project I worked on on PC for development, but that by no means implies that the PC client was ready for release when the console versions launched. Usually very very far from it. Most of the time the PC version only worked with Nvidia GPUs and only on a specific driver version that we were locked into, and then making the game into a releasable version meant taking literally months optimizing it for all kinds of hardware that's out there. For intel gpus we literally spent two months with Intel engineers making sure that gamers get a good experience on that hardware. It's not like you can just package the exe put it on steam and ship it.
        • omnimus 15 hours ago
          Also mouse and keyboard? There are often sigificant changes because the ux and difficulty might be very different with mouse and keyboard.
        • dalmo3 14 hours ago
          Thanks for the perspective. I genuinely believed it was mostly marketing.
      • wolvoleo 15 hours ago
        Well it'll need some testing and stuff, and optimization for different PCs. But it would be relatively easy yes.

        Because rockstar has done this every time I suppose that they get kickbacks from the console vendors. Like an a timed exclusive except this time a multi platform one.

        I really hope this time the AI ports force them to just release it as soon as possible.

      • pezgordo 16 hours ago
        There tons of games running all right on consoles but like crap on pc
    • Fr0styMatt88 17 hours ago
      Yep, this 100%. I’m itching to throw my money at Rockstar. I’m not going to buy a PS5 Pro for it though.
      • dolmen 15 hours ago
        I bought an Xbox (the originalone) for GTA 3. I bought a Nintendo DSi for GTA Chinatown Wars.

        Maybe it's time for me to get a PS5.

        • wolvoleo 15 hours ago
          I bought an Xbox 360 for GTA IV.

          I started playing a lot of xbox because at the time I didn't have money for a game pc. And it died after a couple years due to RROD. Just out of warranty of course.

          Then I got the newer "Jasper" model which also died after a few years and finally the slim.

          But at that point VR came on the scene and I got a PC instead. I've also had faulty components there over time but I never went the console way again. I don't want to buy a whole new console every time it breaks.

        • viccis 14 hours ago
          I'm thinking the same but a PS5 Pro is a rough price to justify lol. If I do it, it will be because I want to play stuff like Bloodborne, etc., on it too.
    • sudosysgen 18 hours ago
      I think it's quite clear that the delay in PC ports here is almost certainly to allow for double dipping, as they think they'll be able to sell the same player the console and PC version.
      • robot_jesus 18 hours ago
        Well, that and studios always get paid a premium for console releases before PC. Especially if it’s an exclusive.
      • lossolo 17 hours ago
        I think it's mostly because the console versions weren't cracked, so if you wanted to play GTA V you had no choice but to buy it, unless you wanted to wait a year for a PC version.
    • kanemcgrath 17 hours ago
      Piracy is a service issue, And I have not been serviced!
      • guax 15 hours ago
        Same! I either want the transferable console disc or the pc version. No way I am shelling this amount of money for a console version that I won’t be able to replay in the future or will always be the same experience (30 fps).

        GTAV is playable on a steam deck today. I hope that VI will be playable in the future mobile thing that exists or just a better pc at better frame rate.

      • Onavo 17 hours ago
        And pricing issue. A Benjamin is a lot of money in most parts of the world.
        • kanemcgrath 17 hours ago
          I would drop a Benjamin if only Rockstar would let me. RDR2 is in my top 5 so I have no doubt GTA6 will be worth it, but it is not worth buying a PS5 or xbox just to play it
          • jack_pp 17 hours ago
            Buy the console, play it for a few weeks, return it, sell the game
            • wolvoleo 15 hours ago
              You can't use it that much and return it. At least not around here.
              • jack_pp 15 hours ago
                isn't amazon known to accept returns pretty much in all cases? don't you have 30 days?

                LE: or you can just buy one used on craigslist and re-sell it after a month or two.

                • wolvoleo 14 hours ago
                  I'm not sure but for the price of a console I wouldn't make that bet. Under local EU law you can use a product but just to determine if it's good for you. Playing a whole game and then returning won't fly.

                  I think at the end of the year Amazon allows returns until February but still, I don't think it's fair and they would be right to refuse.

                  Besides it's impossible to find one on Amazon right now anyway.

    • EA-3167 18 hours ago
      I think it has more to do with the fact that this time they had thirteen years and an unlimited budget to work with.
  • tjpnz 15 hours ago
    How likely is a recomp for Mac like there was for OOT?
    • sxp 5 hours ago
      It won't technically be a "recomp" which involves `x86 binary -> x86 source -> identical x86 binary` in a loop by AIs. But we might get `x86 source -> ARM source` as a Mac port a few weeks after the PC port is working.
    • Roxo 13 hours ago
      Less likely, as GTA VI is made for x86 hardware while Apple chips are Arm architectures. Zelda OoT is made for Switch 2 (also Arm architecture), so recompilation is much easier in that case.
  • expedition32 9 hours ago
    Most game developers have embraced PC gaming and release on Steam day one. Hype is ephemeral after all.
  • gbraad 17 hours ago
    It is using a dump from Cyberleek and awaiting the .exe (this Monday?). So, sure they use kind words, but nothing is based on their own retrieved backup files.

    The describe behaviour of locating the game files is just how an agent thought it would be smart to locate the files.

    I feels like this is not anything ethical, but rather hiding as a cheap way to play the game through a leak, and using AI to get there. The grudge argument 'no physical' has been mentioned, but I am not buying that in this case.

    • wolvoleo 14 hours ago
      The grudge "no PC release" is why I'd use it.

      I know, I know, they've always done it. But I've always hated that and would have played a pirate copy if I could have.

      I never really pirate games but in this case yes I would. They just generate so much hype around it.

      • gbraad 14 hours ago
        I do not buy the grudge argument;sure, I hate Sony for banning my account, for which they were responsible due to the PSN hack, I dislike th fact they announced to stop producing disc, but they also did this for CDs. I don't think they did right by removing movies from people's accounts. I don't like GTA6 is download only,... But this is a wider spread issue. All downloads are at risk.

        Piracy is not justified, as that is theft. If you legally obtained a copy, this is a different story,... As n that case getting access to those same files is OK, and emulation is justified. I am just torn here as it feels it is this is made in to the hype you say to justify piracy for not having a PC release.

        BTW, go ahead and get this if it works. Sony lost me as a customer forever, as it was unlawful what they did, they took advantage of the situation I was/am in a different geolocation as expat.

        • ada-h00k 6 hours ago
          Piracy is justified because Rockstar Games makes it impossible to obtain the files legally. If they aren't going to release a PC version, they should at least offer buyers of the PS5 or Xbox version the option to download the files legally. It's the same with Nintendo. I wouldn't have a problem buying Ocarina of Time if it were simply available for download without me needing a physical Switch 2 to play it.
          • generichuman 2 hours ago
            Ocarina of Time is available for you to play without a Switch 2 as long as you can dump the cartridge yourself, so that part of the argument is a bit shaky.

            Also they're not under an obligation to provide their games to PC gamers, keep that in mind.

        • u8080 6 hours ago
          I bought GTA: Definitive edition on release and allocated weekends to play SA.

          Rockstar removed game from my library without even notifying me(they found some copyright issues in their OST, but I dont care). They also refused to return money for the product I've spent it on. Fortunately, payment gateway(Xsolla) refunded me full price.

          You know, you dont experience such shit with pirated software.

        • thenthenthen 6 hours ago
          I miss the days of demos. This made me buy games. Im not gonna spend 100usd on a thing that im not even sure of how it will run. So high seas first. If i like, if it runs, I buy. Same with music really, but atleast you get some snippets there now and then.
      • m4rtink 10 hours ago
        Yeah, there is no good reason for why they don't have a PC version other than money grabbing, potentially combined with shady exclusivity deals.

        If anything it would make more sense to do the mainstream platform (PC) first and then maybe the consoles for the few people who still have them.

        So for doing the other way around they deserve what is coming.

        • zoogies 5 hours ago
          > If anything it would make more sense to do the mainstream platform (PC) first and then maybe the consoles for the few people who still have them.

          I think you have a very fundamental misunderstanding as to where the majority of their sales come from. PC is just a drop in the bucket for Rockstar.

          > Yeah, there is no good reason for why they don't have a PC version other than money grabbing, potentially combined with shady exclusivity deals.

          It could be a tiny bit of both, but plenty of games release on consoles first because of fixed performance targets, and then take the time to enhance and optimize for PC. In this case, Rockstar is also releasing online later down the line too, but I don’t see anybody chastising them for that

  • Rzor 20 hours ago
    I'm sure Rockstar is reconsidering postponing the PC release too much now. lol
    • turpentine 19 hours ago
      That depends how much the console exclusive deals were worth. Also, surely their lawyers can just pick up the phone and call Microsoft's lawyers to expedite the takedown of piracy attempts hosted on github.
      • drnick1 19 hours ago
        The project will just move elsewhere, nobody needs GitHub, it's just convenient.
      • Rzor 15 hours ago
        There's no console exclusivity deals. It's a prerogative of Rockstar to release the PC version later and make gamers double dip. Also their other cash cow is GTA Online, and PC notoriously gives them very little money for it.

        >Zelnick said the window of console exclusivity was not related to the company’s marketing deal with PlayStation maker Sony Group Corp. “No,” he said. “I mean, historically Rockstar's gone to console first.”

        https://unwall.app/www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-05-0...

      • dlcarrier 19 hours ago
        [dead]
    • ahartmetz 19 hours ago
      That is probably much more true than anyone on the not-illegal side of things is willing to admit in public.
      • ls612 19 hours ago
        The rumors I’ve heard is that they are targeting internally a Q1 release for PC and that is no doubt due to AI making a port/recomp/emulation inevitable on short timeframes.
  • superdisk 19 hours ago
    > Everything that can be done without the game's executable is in place, so work on booting can start as soon as one is available to a developer.

    Glad they have the logo and name locked in before even getting a copy of the game.

    • ACCount39 19 hours ago
      "Getting a copy" is not as trivial as grabbing one off a disk. Dumping the actual executable involves breaking parts of console's DRM - they tend to ship encrypted.

      So far, no one who did that has leaked the executable, or encryption keys, or something like "encrypted executable XOR decrypted executable" that would allow people to decrypt their own dumps.

      But it's a matter of time. Either the Xbox side will leak, or the PS5 side will.

      • satvikpendem 18 hours ago
        You're right but the parent is being sarcastic.
      • therein 17 hours ago
        I was under the impression Cyberleek was going to post the Xbox executable in the next few days. He posted every other asset already.
        • ACCount39 2 hours ago
          I don't know off the top of my head of the executable and the rest of the assets are encrypted in the same way.

          The leaker may have access to one but not the other, and overclaiming.

  • maxglute 13 hours ago
    15 year old agent kiddie bringing down console hardware industry, and making console games "accessible" to billions > solving riemann. Wonder how much time before RAGE engine gets "open sourced", LBH no other developer was going to catch up to Rockstar.
  • lyu07282 13 hours ago
    Seems a bit premature to just trust the word of a cyber vegetable that they will release a executable and won't it just be an early dev build anyway?
  • rvz 19 hours ago
    I predict that this will be taken down by the end of the year.

    So clone it before it gets a DMCA takedown.

    • DannyBee 18 hours ago
      Hookshot (same dev,same type of project) got taken down but is now back up, as are forks (longshot, etc).
    • wavemode 13 hours ago
      Does this GitHub project even contain any Rockstar Games intellectual property? My understanding is that you have to provide a copy of the game for this code to do anything.
    • GCUMstlyHarmls 18 hours ago
      radicle.dev though I assume they'll hit agent roadblocks too if not already.
    • wolvoleo 15 hours ago
      Doesn't matter. It'll just move somewhere else.
    • oh_no 18 hours ago
      it's not particularly usable now and will move elsewhere if github takes it down
    • hsuduebc2 19 hours ago
      I would be surprised if it last to the end of the week.
  • tomlockwood 19 hours ago
    All that's left to do is draw the rest of the owl.
  • drnick1 17 hours ago
    Can someone explain what makes the GTA games so popular? I bought GTA 5 on Steam a few years ago on sale for a few bucks, and was utterly bored a couple hours in. I haven't launched the game since.
    • shepherdjerred 16 hours ago
      I've never played GTA, but I bought GTA 6 since my office has an Xbox and there was a lot of hype.

      It's a fun game! I tend to really dislike modern AAA games -- they just feel off, but I really like GTA 6.

      The graphics are quite good and the world feels alive. They clearly put a lot of love into this.

    • npteljes 13 hours ago
      It's multiple things, but it's ultimately a violence focused sandbox. And now that the game is advanced, there is a lot of other things to do, drive around, fish, hunt, fly planes, dress up and pose the characters.

      Personally, gta stories were pretty mid to me, I just liked raising hell in them, especially younger. However, rdr2 story I rather liked. And now gtavi gives much more a modernized rdr feeling, than a "traditional" gta feeling.

    • jmyeet 16 hours ago
      Ok, I have a lot of opinions on this. First, ignore GTA 1 and 2. They're different games.

      Where GTA defined a genre was with GTA 3, which was the first open world 3D title of the series and it was reasonably early in the 3D open world era. But what set it apart other than the story was the humor and the satire. The action was comical but it was also social commentary, like it was intentional how bad cops were at their job. That wasn't lazy programming.

      This only continued with GTA 3 Vice City and then GTA San Andreas. The graphics got better, the worlds got larger and the satire stayed relevant and got better (IMHO). And then after a few years we got GTA 4, which was my favorite of the series. This is controversial. It was the first to tackle having the Internet and smartphones (pre-iPhone) in the game and it did it well.

      And then came GTA V. My hot take is that GTA V isn't a very good game. Many consider it the best of the series. To me, it had none of the satire and social commentary. It was... bland. Beautiful graphics but... bland. And formulaic. In previous versions I would play just to mess around shooting down helicopters and the like. I almost quit the GTA V story multiple times (eg when I got to Trevor). The characters and writing was (IMHO) just awful. And since I finished the story I've never played it again. That was a first for me in the GTA series.

      What a lot of people liked was GTA V Online. This never held any interest to me. Yet others got into GTA RP (role play), which is huge and is going to be huge in GTA 6. It was also a massive cash cow for Rockstar. It will be again for GTA 6.

      So if you don't like GTA V there could be good reason. I might suggest picking up the earlier games on a Steam sales (they're typically a few dollars each) depending on your tolerance for 20+ year old graphics.

      • thenthenthen 6 hours ago
        Played all the gta’s from the start to finish, multiple times. Standouts are 1, 3, vice city (+ballad of gay tony) and 5. I really could not get into 4, janky pc controls (driving) might had something to do with it). I think 5 had better, modern, social commentary than all the others?
    • justsomehnguy 17 hours ago
      Did you play with cars or whatever toys in your childhood? Like completely with the imaginary scenarios, like "Mr. Truck tramples these disgusting soldiers of (your sister's) evil villain Barbierella", voiced SFX and so on?

      Same deal. Sandbox where you can have fun. Sure, playing golf or hitting a gym in GTA5 is for.. a certain people but making a mayhem across the city is certainly a endearing way to spend some time and relax.

    • gbraad 17 hours ago
      It is a repetitive game loop, but it combines a few aspect that most people like: cars, destruction, etc.

      I also can't play this for a long time, but outrunning the cops is fun,... Although Butnout Legends like crashes would have made it cooler.

      You'll have to settle for the "wasted" screen

      • fzzzy 10 hours ago
        They have slo mo crashes in 6
        • gbraad 6 hours ago
          Final crashes, right. Not like in bunout while still driving... if so, that's cool
  • tamimio 19 hours ago
    Once it’s released to PC officially, modders will improve the game in a year what rockstar took to do in a decade.
    • mjmvisser 18 hours ago
      I think it will be more like days. I never thought my skills would be obsolete and it’s happened in under a year. Claude may not be as good as the best of us, but it’s ten to a hundred times faster depending on the task.
      • qwerpy 17 hours ago
        I'm waiting to get the game on PC until AI-powered modders have fully unlocked it back to the unrestricted GTA mayhem of past decades. Much of it should hopefully be trivial with AI. Remove the flags on X locations or Y NPCs that prohibits certain actions, add back certain NPCs that provide health benefits, enable unlimited room in the inventory, remove having to do chores to make an NPC happy, etc. Sometimes I want to just load up the game and blast everything in sight, or power through a game without having to do all the side quests to see all the content.

        I'll probably be getting far more games on PC than on consoles going forward, so that I can bend the game to my will.

      • jmyeet 16 hours ago
        This is going to come up for GTA RP (role play), which has a pretty large community around it. This was once text based, like just emoting text, but there were servers for multiplayer shared state.

        By the time of GTA V, this got pretty sophisticated. Instead of emotes, you had physical emotes that were animated by RP developers. They'd created a bunch of in-game systems. There were VoIP clients added for proximity chat and so on. One of the more famous servers was (and is) NoPixel. Rockstar hired a chunk (or all?) of the NoPixel team to develop GHTA 6 RP natively instead of hacking into the client. That's going to be huge.

        But all those in-game RP features will have to be created again from scratch pretty much in GTA 6 but now we have AI tools that will make it so much easier, to your point. I believe the pace of development will be rapid and there will be a bewildering amount of vibecoded cosmetic, in-game systems, multiplayer state and technical features that will be added to RP.

      • bigstrat2003 16 hours ago
        Claude isn't even as good as the average programmer, let alone the best. And being faster isn't actually advantageous when it isn't good. For throwaway things it isn't hugely important to get it right, but only fools are just letting Claude rip on production systems for business. It simply is nowhere near good enough to do that.
        • gambiting 15 hours ago
          Hard disagree there. I work in video games and AI can one shot bugs that would have taken a normal programmer days unless they were already extremely familiar with the area - like you can literally go "the game crashes on the switch when the player does action X, here's a core dump, go" and it will either straight up find the issue immediately or it will get you 98% there. I've worked in games for a long time now and I love being thrown at all kinds of weird and unsolvable crashes and then spending hours looking over logs and GPU dumps, but I would be absolutely stupid to pretend like AI can't do this faster than I can.

          For implementing brand new features - we can have a discussion here, there's definitely issues with even the best agents at doing large scale big engine changes. But bug solving and adding small-ish things in an existing code base it will do much faster than a human would, purely because it can find the right place and understand the layout of the code almost instantly.

        • misiek08 13 hours ago
          I'm straight jealous if you live in a place where average programmer is better than Claude. Around me I would say 70-75% are way worse in quality and 99% slower. I think in a version or two Opus will eat next 10%, so my position would switch completely to architect/builder, because now sometimes there still are challenges using our (human) knowledge, skill and experience to direct agents in correct direction.
  • stefangordon 19 hours ago
    .
    • LatticeAnimal 19 hours ago
      That is obviously to avoid piracy claims, not to get someone to share a copy of GTA-6.

      If they distributed Rockstar assets the repo would certainly be removed and rockstar could pursue legal action. As-is, this repo only enables people to modify their own owned copies of the game.

      • wolvoleo 15 hours ago
        I'm sure rockstar will pursue anyway. Some lawyers are already drooling and drafting up hundred thousand dollar invoices this very Sunday I'm sure.
    • SXX 19 hours ago
      To recompile something you need decrypted executable that's not yet been leaked.

      Supposedly someone might just drop one tomorrow or after tomorrow and this is why they want to prepare for xbox retargeting recompiler to work since before no one ever worked on one.

      This ia much morw real than actual new playstation / xbox hack because for this "port" someone just need to dump decrypted gta 6 executable fron memory exactly once. Not craft reproducible non-destructive jailbreak,

    • ebrahimh 19 hours ago
      Should have clarified, not my repo, found this linked in a reddit post and saw it had a lot of stars

      just wanted to see people's opinions on it!

  • bakugo 19 hours ago
    Apparently the lead "developer" (vibe coder) on this is a 15 year old who doesn't realize he's going to spend the rest of his life giving half of his paycheck to Take Two.
    • ebrahimh 18 hours ago
      This dev also led a similar project (https://github.com/ItsNotRexed/Hookshot) that targets the new Ocarina Of Time remake

      Apparently this Hookshot project was forked into https://git.magicbean.dev/MagicBeanDev/Longshot because the codebase was badly organized (vibe coded)

    • blntechie 17 hours ago
      I love the hacking spirit. If that is not appreciated in HN, where else?

      Now when their parents realize what their kid had been doing.

    • Manuel_D 14 hours ago
      Open source engine projects are legal, from what I can tell. OpenMW is one example, some of the total war series like M2EX is a another. No copyrighted assets are being distributed. No DRM protection is being circumvented since it's a whole new executable.

      The famous Nintendo case involved selling devices go bypass copyright protection, not open source implementations of Nintendo engines.

    • SXX 19 hours ago
      They can scare this exact guy, buy they cant do anything with recompiler itself.
    • superdisk 15 hours ago
      Damn. Being a professional software developer really is over. The future is just endless script kiddies. It was fun while it lasted.
    • ReptileMan 16 hours ago
      For what exactly?
    • whamlastxmas 18 hours ago
      This feels like some scare tactic by take two cronies